As Tesla's stock witnessed a drastic decline in value following a meteoric rise in November, a quiet but intense market maneuver began to unfold centered around the fluctuations of Tesla's stock priceAnalysts and investors, quick to recognize an emerging trend, identified new trading opportunities primarily through the strategy of closing out Tesla trades, seen not just as a hedge against market sell-offs, but also as a potentially lucrative trading opportunity.

The rationale behind this trading strategy isn't particularly complexDespite the recent plummet in Tesla's stock prices, its valuation remains the highest among leading tech companies when aligned with its expected earningsCurrently, Tesla boasts an eye-watering expected price-to-earnings ratio of 109, while the average for the Bloomberg U.S. tech giants price return index stands at around 30, and the S&P 500 index hovers at a mere 22. This stark contrast suggests that Tesla's stock could still have a pathway for further decline, offering a fundamental backing for bearish options trading strategies.

Moreover, the skyrocketing prices of Tesla's shares were partially fueled by irrational factors

Advertisements

Hopes were high that Elon Musk's newfound political clout would pave the way for Tesla to achieve its ambitious goal of fully autonomous vehicles, causing Tesla's stock to deviate from its fundamentals and exhibit excessive strengthNow, as the market returns to a more rational evaluation, that surge driven by emotion and expectation has begun to wane, putting additional pressure on Tesla's stock price to correct.

Michael Purves, CEO of Tallbacken Capital Advisors, astutely sensed this market signal, asserting that it presents a prime opportunity to engage in a Tesla put spreadThe strategy he described involves buying put options with a strike price of $300 while simultaneously selling put options with a strike price of $250, aimed to expire in MayEarlier this month, implied volatility dipped to the lower end of its range for the past year, significantly reducing the cost of options protectionThis decrease in cost undoubtedly enhances the allure of trading, especially for those hoping to balance some of the total cost by selling lower strike options.

Purves remarked, "While this is a straightforward directional trade, we also believe it serves as a quasi-market hedge." His perspective is rooted in a deep understanding of market dynamicsStocks like Tesla, heavily influenced by momentum and sentiment, tend to face substantial sell-offs when market sentiment shifts, particularly during periods of heightened selling pressureThus, by buying a put spread, investors can not only profit during decreases in Tesla's stock value but can also hedge against the risks that broader market sell-offs may poseNevertheless, Purves noted, "If the market continues to trade sideways or move higher, this trade still boasts a favorable risk-reward profile." This is due to the fact that, even if Tesla's stock does not drop as anticipated, the income generated from selling lower strike options can somewhat offset potential losses, allowing the entire trading strategy to maintain a degree of flexibility across different market conditions.

Beyond valuation and market sentiment factors, technical indicators also signaled negative trends for Tesla's stock price

Advertisements

On Tuesday, the stock fell by 6.3% for the fifth consecutive trading day and breached the significant 100-day moving averageThis critical technical breakdown is usually interpreted as a vital signal of waning price momentum, further amplifying the market’s bearish outlook on Tesla.

Investor sentiment within the options market has also seen a notable shiftPreviously, options traders were inclined to bet that Tesla's stock would continue benefitting from upward momentum, but their outlook has grown less optimisticFor the first time since November in the U.S., the premiums for one-month call options relative to put options have disappearedIn recent days, after a steady decline since the start of the year, volatility has begun to rise again, indicating that traders are not only less keen on purchasing call options but are also willing to pay higher prices for contracts designed to protect against further price declinesThis series of changes reflects a fundamental shift in market sentiment regarding Tesla's stock, with bearish perspectives gradually prevailing.

Since peaking in mid-December, Tesla's stock has plummeted by 32%, resulting in a staggering loss of approximately $484 billion in market capitalizationThis hefty drop has not only prompted investors to reevaluate Tesla's investment worthiness but has also ignited concerns about the company's future prospectsMoreover, in recent weeks, a slew of negative news surrounding the company has piled on the pessimismThe disappointing fourth-quarter earnings report disclosed at the end of last month raised doubts over its profitability; subsequently, significant drops in sales figures across Europe, China, and even California have drawn widespread concernThese interwoven negative factors have further exacerbated the market's bearish expectations on Tesla's stock price.